“It's very undemanding, but it's inventive... Zoey Deutch makes a sweet heroine and her costars... are pleasant company.” Rotten Tomatoes
Reviewers from various community platforms shared their personal takes on the film's "coziness" and its lead performance: Something from Tiffany's YIFY
: The film captures the "magic and excitement" of New York City during the holidays, from Bryant Park to Fifth Avenue, creating a wistful, romantic backdrop. Critical & Audience Consensus Rotten Tomatoes 73% (Critics) Derivative but bolstered by good chemistry. Metacritic Mixed or average reviews; "glossy but mindless." A "comfort food" watch that is "inventive enough." Human Voice Quotes “It's very undemanding, but it's inventive
: Zoey Deutch is the clear standout, with reviewers at The New York Times noting her "buoyant verve" and "screwball banter". Kendrick Sampson provides a solid, compassionate foil as the romantic lead. Critical & Audience Consensus Rotten Tomatoes 73% (Critics)
“Someone should tell Zoey Deutch that charisma is not enough to create a character.” Metacritic