“Forgettable but works thanks to Torrey DeVitto's effortless charm.” Rotten Tomatoes
Critics from sites like unobtainium13 and What to Watch suggest it hits the expected emotional beats of a holiday rom-com, though the ending can feel rushed as it quickly ties up all loose ends. Best Christmas Party Ever (2014)
Lead duo is highly liked; Steve Lund is praised for "boyish charm". Neutral High High production value for New York Christmas aesthetics
Some find it boring/slow, while others enjoy the focus on planning adversity. High High production value for New York Christmas aesthetics. Best Christmas Party Ever (TV Movie 2014) Many viewers noted that their banter and performance
Some reviewers noted that the protagonist, Jennie, can come across as overly rigid or "vacant," defined primarily by one childhood memory of a toy store party. Community Perspectives
The strongest asset of the film is the chemistry between Torrey DeVitto and Steve Lund . Many viewers noted that their banter and performance elevated a standard script.
“This was a wonderful movie with a lovely plot and a great ending.” Letterboxd · 4 months ago “Parties can change lives, too.” Letterboxd · 7 months ago Reviewer Sentiment Acting Positive